Happy birthday! Have some carrots
School cupcake bans raise sour objections
By Seema Mehta
Tribune Newspapers: Los Angeles Times
Published October 1, 2006
LOS ANGELES -- The days of the birthday cupcake--smothered in a slurry of sticky frosting and with a dash of rainbow sprinkles--may be numbered in schoolhouses across the nation.
Fears of childhood obesity have led schools to discourage and sometimes even ban what were once de rigueur grammar-school treats.
"They can bring carrots," said Laura Ott, assistant to the superintendent of Orange County's Saddleback Valley Unified School District, which just started limiting non-nutritious classroom treats to three times per year. "A birthday doesn't have to be associated with food."
Such nutritional dictates have ignited a series of cupcake mini-rebellions across the country, and Texas has led the way.
The Texas Legislature last year passed the so-called Safe Cupcake amendment, which guarantees parents' right to deliver unhealthful treats to the classroom, such as sweetheart candies on Valentine's Day and candy corn on Halloween. Rep. Jim Dunnam sponsored the legislation after a school in his district booted out a father bringing birthday pizzas to his child's class.
"There's a lot of reasons our kids are getting fat," said Dunnam, a Democrat from Waco. "Cupcakes aren't one of them."
Whether cookies, cakes and other birthday treats at school are the culprits or not, the nation's children definitely are packing on the pounds.
Nearly 19 percent of children ages 6 to 11 and more than 17 percent of adolescents ages 12 to 19 were overweight in 2003-04, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Extra weight carries health risks, as seen in the increasing childhood diagnoses of Type 2 diabetes.
Obesity concerns led to last year's ban on junk-food and soda sales in California schools. Recent laws by states and the federal government also have prompted school districts throughout the nation to overhaul their nutrition and wellness policies.
"It is a very serious problem, and some districts are looking not only to change what is offered and sold during lunchtime but what is being provided during" the rest of the school day, said Martin Gonzalez, assistant executive director of the California School Boards Association.
`Give me a break'
The crackdown on cupcakes and cookies, a tradition fondly remembered by generations of parents, is often the touchiest.
"That's just ridiculous. Give me a break," said Alexandria Coronado, a member of the Orange County Board of Education and mother of a 15-year-old. "People kill for my fudge."
Although nutritionists endorse promoting healthful eating in schools, some question the logic of making any popular food taboo.
"The more you restrict these special foods--cakes or sweets or whatever--they become even more valued by children. It can almost kind of backfire," said Dr. Nancy Krebs, co-chairwoman of the American Academy of Pediatrics' Task Force on Obesity. "You want to have a kind of pragmatic approach that sweets and desserts are OK in moderation and not put them up on a pedestal."
When the Santa Clara Unified School District in Northern California began reviewing its nutrition policy a year ago, public meetings devolved into shouting matches when the staff recommended banning all junk food from campus, including at school football games.
"It got very heated," said Roger Barnes, an administrator of the 13,000-student district.
In August, the district board decided to ban selling unhealthful food from vending machines and to prohibit teachers from dishing out candy as a reward. But they granted a reprieve to birthday cupcake parties and cheese-dripping nachos at football games.
"They're trying to appease everyone," complained Noelani Sallings, who has two daughters in the district and is running for the school board in November. "American waistlines are getting larger and larger."
Los Angeles is among many neutral territories when it comes to birthday treats at schools.
"There's no central directive," said Susan Cox, spokeswoman for the Los Angeles Unified School District. "We try to encourage parents to consider healthy alternatives."
In San Francisco, parents are encouraged to supply parties with fruit, celery sticks stuffed with low-fat cream cheese, whole-wheat pita triangles and hummus, and zucchini bread.
Some schools are going further.
In the Duxbury Public School District in Massachusetts, parents and educators on the Chandler School Council decided to forgo all classroom treats two years ago, Supt. Eileen Williams said.
Other ways to celebrate
"The `ban on cupcakes' was controversial, as it was a long-standing tradition. But most adults could readily see once the new policy was put into place that the new ways of recognizing birthdays in school, including special clothing and seat covers made by the parents, were a delight for the children," Williams wrote in an e-mail.
In Orange County, Chaparral Elementary Principal Kevin Rafferty decided to ban celebratory food at his Ladera Ranch school this year after hearing about similar efforts at nearby schools.
"There will be parents that maybe are unaware [and] come in with an armful of cupcakes or doughnuts," he said. "I don't relish those kinds of conversations. At the same time, I want to do what's best for kids."
Rafferty and others noted that in a classroom of 30 students, birthdays, Valentine's Day celebrations, Halloween and other special events can mean dozens of junk-food-laden parties.
"That's a lot of cupcakes over the year," Rafferty said.
Childhood Obesity fight
Linear Mode
